While our shop at DeKalb has been closed this winter, we’ve been doing LOTS of exciting back end stuff here at Robicelli’s. Like taxes! Setting up new accounting software to handle payroll! And (finally) finishing the book proposal! Would you believe that’s just the tip of the iceberg? Seriously!
One of the many projects I’ve been working on is finally coming up with a “graphic identity” for us, which we haven’t really had for the past few years because we were broke and couldn’t afford it. Also, throughout my entire career I’ve seen (and worked for) companies who spend all their efforts branding - creating a slick, glossy corporate package - and then once you look past the logo you find that there’s actually absolutely zero quality and nothing of substance.
Though I can name a thousand graphic designers who will argue otherwise, not having a budget for design ended up being invaluable to us for lots of reasons. For one, it made people notice us on the strength of our product, and not because lots of stuff on our website moved around to trance music. Instead of having a fancy website, we ended up making our internet home here on Tumblr, which was without question the smartest move we could have made as a growing small business (as for all the reasons why- well, that’s another post entirely). Also, trying to make a logo ourselves yielded this:

We made some other ones, too, but I’m trying hard to keep this blog PG-13.
2012 finds us in a new place. We’ve proved that we have substance. We have plans of expansion, and big projects on the way. We’ve got our first whole season at DeKalb starting on April 6th. And after years of hard work, we have a teeny weeny little budget. So one of my projects for this winter was to finally find a designer that answered emails and phone calls, and start working on a comprehensive visual branding profile for Robicelli’s. This blog is going to get itself sexified!!!
After countless interviews with designers who just didn’t get what we were looking for, hours of research, asking around for references, tons of preliminary sketches that we hated, we finally found our designer by screwing around on Facebook. I always think of my old friend Isaac Lubow as the 15 year old kid with a blue mohawk that I went to Stuyvesant High School with. I keep forgetting that since we graduate, he also graduated from Pratt, also became a parent, did some modeling, and opened a graphic design firm in Bali. He also takes the time out of his busy schedule to be one of the funniest people on Twitter, because he’s truly a gift to humanity.
Within 12 hours of talking, three preliminary sketches were in my inbox. Usually when I get sketches, I hate most, if not all of them. This time? HEAD OVER HEELS IN LOVE WITH THEM ALL. Which sucks, because I can’t choose. So I put all three of them up on Facebook and on my personal page, thinking there would be an obvious favorite and I’d just run with that. Except that when I broke down all the comments, they were all voted for equally, all defended by excellent arguments. And I cannot for the life of me decide which one to use as a starting point:

“Easy to read”. “Hands down my favorite”, “Like both the design/font”, “Has the most potential as a first draft”, “Clean & simple”, “Will translate well to packaging”
BUT ”Reminds me of a diner sign and crappy diner cake” “Too Broadway”
_____________________________________________

“Personal, classy and already feels important”, “Reminds me of classic bakeries”, “Love the retro feel”, “Would look good on print materials”, “Reads more gourmet and upmarket”, “Fancier”
BUT ”I think the ‘o’ sort of looks like an ‘a’, so I’m reading it as Rabicelli’s” “Cursive writing is pretentious now, and people under the age of 18 can’t read cursive anymore”
_____________________________________________

“Looks the most iconic and visually arresting”, “Progressive, new, and smacks your mother in the ass then licks your dads nose”, “Very ownable- retro, yet there’s something modern about it” “Like that it says ‘Brooklyn’”, “Will hold up in different sizes”, “The guys from Clutch would pick this logo, and seriously Allison, when do you not listen to the dudes from Clutch”
BUT ”Reminds me of a Soviet Propaganda poster”, “Reminds me of gum” “Cold & sterile”
___________________________________________
And these aren’t even the final drawings! This is the first draft! How has a first draft become do divisive?!?!
This little social media experiment has accomplished the following:
1. Exposed me to the fact that every single person that I know is a designer, or is married to a designer, or has a best friend who’s a designer, or lives next door to a designer, or took design in school once.
2. Given me the worst headache I have had since my I finally finished the book proposal (so, since last Friday)
3. Made me realize that once I pick the first draft, I’m going to have to pick a second draft, then a third, and then we can start talking about color schemes. And this is just for the logo. After that, we redesign the Tumblr. And then packaging. And then the t-shirt and the officially licensed Robicelli’s tracksuits and G-strings. Meaning there’s an excellent chance that by the end of this year, I will be 100% catatonic, but as a small consolation, I will at least be wearing a dope-ass tracksuit. And maybe a G-string, depending on how cold it is.
Isaac told me to just go with my gut and pick one, but even my gut isn’t sure. So we’re doing the only logical thing:
We are making the entire process of branding our company interactive.
I mean really, who knows our company better than you guys- the ones who read our blog, buy our cupcakes, and have been supporting us as we’ve grown? And who are the people who are going to see this logo on shelves, on storefronts, on skimpy underwear? YOU are. So we want you to guide us along, tell us what you want to see, and have your opinions be a part of this company. CLICK HERE TO VOTE FOR YOUR FAVORITE FIRST DRAFT. We’ll tally the votes next week, then keep you updated as we move forward. And when we need to make another decision, we’ll ask you guys first.
Because we loves and respects you guys long time. Super duper for reals. Now celebrate our love by eating some cupcakes!

Clockwise from front: Chocolate PB Pretzel, Duckwalk, Chocolate Merlot, Creamsicle
Chocolate PB Pretzel: Chocolate cake, peanut butter buttercream, crushed peanuts and pretzels
Duckwalk: Vanilla cake, blueberry port mascarpone buttercream, port simmered blueberries
Chocolate Merlot: Chocolate merlot cake & buttercream, chocolate shavings, black pepper
Creamsicle: Orange cake, vanilla buttercream, candied orange peel
___________________________
Cupcakes Available at:
Cafe at Sam’s Bakery: 94th Street off 3rd Avenue, Bay Ridge
Aloha Grinds: 77th & 3rd Ave, Bay Ridge
Bagel Schmagel: 76th & 3rd Ave, Bay Ridge
Blue Apron Foods: Union Street off 7th Ave, Park Slope
Tazza: Clark St off Henry AND Henry St off Atlantic, Brooklyn Heights
Eastern District: Manhattan Ave off Eagle, Greenpoint
Brooklyn Standard: Nassau Street off Jewel, Greenpoint
Cake Shop: Ludlow btwn Stanton & Rivington, LES
Joe Columbia University: West 120th Street btwn Broadway & Amsterdam, Morningside Heights
Bar 5F at Bergdorf Goodman: 5th Avenue & 58th Street, 5th Floor, Manhattan
Queen City Cupcakes: Patchogue, Long Island
________________________________
Whoopie Pies Available At:
Red Hook Lobster Pound: 284 Van Brunt Street, Red Hook
Tazza: Clark St off Henry AND Henry St off Atlantic, Brooklyn Heights
Queen City Cupcakes: West Main Street, Patchogue, Long Island
_________________________________
Brownies Available At:
Queen City Cupcakes: West Main Street, Patchogue, Long Island
Oaxaca Tacos: 250 4th Avenue- Park Slope Brooklyn; 251 Smith Street Cobble Hill Brooklyn; 16 Extra Place, LES Manhattan